Modi Picks AIR, DD As
Media Brands Of Choice
source:http://www.businessinsider.in/
|
Prime Minister Narendra Modi has
anointed India's state-backed broadcaster as his media brand of choice,
helping shield his government from tough questions and prompting private
news outlets to complain that they are being kept out of the loop.
Starchy and unpolished, Doordarshan News and All India Radio (AIR) were
not the obvious choice for a government that took power in May after a
high-octane election campaign that used special effects to beam Modi's
image to rallies across the nation.
But the old-fashioned outlets are expected to offer one big advantage over
their slicker private rivals: a less combative and questioning platform
from which Modi can get his message out to tens of millions of Indians.
Carefully controlled communication has been a defining characteristic of
the new government since Modi's nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party swept
to power.
Critics see it as one symptom of a broader leadership style under Modi
that has weakened opponents, sidelined ministers and concentrated power in
the Prime Minister's Office (PMO).
Information and Broadcasting Minister Prakash Javadekar said Modi's
preference for the public broadcaster was not an attempt to suppress
information or limit access.
"I think everyone must welcome it. He has not banned anybody, his
programmes are telecast live, practically on all channels, so where is the
issue? There is no denying somebody access."
"There is complete freedom in our regime," he told reporters.
PMO officials were not available to comment for this story.
"FROM THE HEART"
Modi has never given a news conference as prime minister, but he has been
active on Facebook and Twitter, where he has over 7 million followers,
bypassing traditional media and spurring editors to complain about a lack
of two-way communication and debate.
Now, for the first time, an Indian prime minister has a direct link to
voters' living rooms in his home.
Last month, the state broadcaster set up a recording studio at Modi's
official residence where he will record "Man ki Baat" ("talking from the
heart"), his regular address to the nation on AIR that debuted earlier in
October.
Doordarshan has been contracted to build a television studio at Modi's
residence so his talk can be televised as well, according to an engineer
working on the project.
Separately, the government has sent a letter asking ministries to engage
more with the publicly funded broadcaster, according to the India Today
news website, and has given its journalists coveted spots in a
significantly reduced press corps that travels with the prime minister
overseas.
Thirty or more journalists usually travelled with the previous prime
minister. But on Modi's recent trip to the United States, only nine - the
majority from state-funded organisations - accompanied him, according to
the foreign ministry.
Private news outlets say diminishing interaction with the government has
made their jobs harder.
"There has been a lot of communication from the government, but it's been
very top-down," said N. Ravi, editor of the Hindu newspaper and president
of the Editors Guild of India, which issued a statement in September
calling on the government to interact more with journalists. "It's been a
one-way street."
The Guild statement noted "a certain deficit of transparency in the
functioning of the government," citing the delay in setting up a media
liaison in the PMO and restricting access to ministers and bureaucrats.
BAD BLOOD
Modi has had rocky relations with the media since 2002, when at least
1,000 people, mostly Muslims, died in religious riots in Gujarat state,
where he was chief minister at the time.
Local and international media reported extensively on the violence, raised
questions about the state government's role and some blamed Modi for
failing to stop the brutality.
Modi has always denied any wrongdoing, and courts have never found
sufficient evidence to prosecute him.
But the relationship remained fraught. Since 2002 his aides have routinely
requested journalists to present their questions in advance as a condition
to secure a formal meeting with him.
In 2007, Modi abruptly walked out of an interview with a private Indian
news channel when he was asked whether he regretted the 2002 incidents.
Modi sat through an interview with Reuters last year, dismissing concerns
about his style of management and saying that he welcomed criticism
because "the strength of democracy lies in criticism".
Since taking office Modi has not given an interview to the Indian media,
though he has spoken with foreign news outlets ahead of trips abroad.
"Even for the positives of the government to be brought out, a certain
amount of access is necessary," said NDTV political editor Rahul
Shrivastava, who has covered the PMO since the mid-1990s.
Now, he said, "you have to accept [information] as it comes - both in
terms and quality and quantity."
In June, Information and Broadcasting Minister Javadekar said he would
give Prasar Bharati, the state body that operates AIR and Doordarshan,
more autonomy and editorial freedom. The government's new reliance on
these networks may complicate that.
The government asked ministries to strengthen ties with state-run
broadcasters because of their national reach, Bimal Julka, secretary of
Javadekar's ministry, told Reuters.
The government wants information "to penetrate to the last mile", he said,
but it is "distorted" by some private outlets and so public broadcasters
also need to distribute the facts.
|||||| Thank
you for your interest.||||||
|