To hire or to buy? DD faces dilemma
Source:http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com
|
Mundane furniture like chairs,
dustbins and wall clocks got the public broadcaster, Doordarshan (DD), tied
in knots whether to hire or buy the stuff. Finally, it took a rap on the
knuckles by the finance wing of the Prasar Bharati to end the four-month
impasse.
The bone of contention is a contract
upwards of Rs 1 crore to provide customised furniture that was given by DD
to BECIL, a public sector undertaking. Initially, DD had decided to hire the
furniture. But, estimates furnished by BECIL showed that the cost of hiring
a storage cabinet was Rs 12,500 while purchasing it would have cost Rs
9,800. Pleading paucity of time and lack of "usage", DD felt that the
furniture should be hired. But after objections from the finance wing, there
was a sudden change of heart.
A K Jain of Prasar Bharati (finance) wrote
a note on August 6, pointing out out that despite objections contract had
been awarded without inviting an open tender and even though a decision had
been taken by the Host Broadcaster Monitoring Committee (HBMC) in its May 7
meeting to hire furniture, it had not been implemented for reasons best
known to the authorities.
"The file shuttled from one desk to another for all
this time for no acceptable reason. The delay seeks to defeat the decision
of the HBMC taken after considering the cost benefit aspects of a "buy" or
"hire" decision,specifically rejecting the option of procurement of the
items proposed to be hired at unreasonably high rates," the note said. It
was a case of delaying decisions in the first place, and then further
delaying the implementation of the decision on unacceptable grounds, it
added. Jain refused to comment on the note.
In her defence, Doordarshan director
general Aruna Sharma admitted that there had been some delay in the
procurment process. "There were some delays. But we have now decided to
purchase the furniture. It is made to size and will be delivered in time to
furnish the presentation studios and broadcast compounds," she explained.
BECIL had been awarded a turnkey project of Rs 19.8 crore that included
building 17 broadcast compounds, four presentation studios and furnishing
them.
The 21 venues include four studios of 50 sq
m each at the Jawaharlal Nehru Stadium (for athletics), Major Dhyanchand
Stadium for hockey, R K Khanna Stadium (for tennis) and S P M Swimming
Complex for aquatics. Other venues that will be furnished by BECIL are the
17 broadcast compounds — ranging between 500 sq m and 900 sq m — that will
be located outside the stadiums, and will act as on-site production centres
for all rights holding broadcasters.
||||||
Thank you for your
interest.||||||
|